Head-to-Head Comparison
The Traeger Westwood ($699) and Westwood XL ($799) are the same grill in two sizes — same 18-lb hopper, same WiFIRE controller, same dual-tier cooking, same P.A.L. rail system, same 3-year warranty. The only meaningful difference is cooking area: 653 sq in on the standard versus 823 sq in on the XL. After cross-referencing Traeger's official capacity numbers (the XL fits 28 chicken breasts, 7 rib racks, or 25 burgers simultaneously), reporting from Gear Patrol and GearJunkie, and the honest math on what 170 extra sq in actually costs you, here's the verdict on whether the XL is worth the $100 — or whether the standard Westwood is the better buy for your cooking.
Same grill, two sizes. The only meaningful difference is 170 sq in of cooking area.
TL;DR
The XL adds 170 sq in for $100 — that's $0.59 per square inch of cooking space, which is excellent value if you'll actually use the space. If your typical cook fills less than 80% of a 653 sq in surface, you don't need the XL — the standard Westwood saves you $100 you can spend on pellets, accessories, or meat instead.
By the Numbers
| Spec | Westwood (Standard) | Westwood XL |
|---|---|---|
| Price (MSRP) | $699.99 | $799.99 |
| Total Cooking Area | 653 sq in | 823 sq in (+26%) |
| Pellet Hopper Capacity | 18 lbs | 18 lbs |
| Temperature Range | 180–450°F | 180–450°F |
| Controller | Same digital button-based | Same digital button-based |
| WiFIRE Wi-Fi + Bluetooth | Yes | Yes |
| Wired Probe Ports | 1 | 1 |
| Wireless Probe Compatible | Yes (+$80 sold separately) | Yes (+$80 sold separately) |
| P.A.L. Pop-and-Lock Rail | Yes | Yes |
| ModiFIRE Compatibility | Yes | Yes |
| Side Shelf | Built-in | Built-in |
| Bottom Storage Shelf | Yes | Yes |
| Dual-Tier Cooking | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 3-year limited | 3-year limited |
| Assembly Time | ~60 min, two-person | ~70–80 min, two-person (heavier) |
| Available | Currently shipping | Currently shipping |
Notice what's identical: hopper, controller, Wi-Fi, probe spec, accessories, warranty, temperature range. The XL is not a "better" grill — it's a bigger grill. Anyone telling you the XL has features the standard doesn't is misreading Traeger's own spec sheet.
Real Capacity
Cooking-area numbers feel abstract until you map them to real food. Here's what each Westwood actually fits, based on Traeger's published capacity numbers and proportional math for the standard model.
| Food | Westwood (653 sq in) | Westwood XL (823 sq in) |
|---|---|---|
| Chicken breasts | ~22 | 28 |
| Burger patties (4-inch) | ~19 | 25 |
| Pork rib racks (full) | ~5 | 7 |
| Whole chickens (5-lb each) | 3 | 4 |
| Pork shoulders (8-lb each) | 2 | 3 |
| Briskets (12-lb each, packer cut) | 1 | 2 |
| Pizza (12-inch) | 2 simultaneously | 3 simultaneously |
| Rib racks + 2 sides | Yes (tight fit) | Yes (comfortable) |
| Thanksgiving turkey (15-lb) + sides | Tight — likely two batches | Single batch with room to spare |
The standard Westwood handles every weeknight cook and most weekend BBQs comfortably. The XL becomes essential when you're feeding 8+ people regularly or batch-smoking multiple primals. If you've never run out of grill space on your current setup, you don't need the XL.
Real Use Cases
Pulled pork freezes excellently, but a single 8-lb shoulder yields ~6 lbs of pulled meat — about 12 servings. If you batch-smoke 4 shoulders at once (XL handles, standard doesn't), you've stocked the freezer for 3 months in one cook. The math: $100 XL premium amortized over 3 months of meat = $33/month, which is less than the time-and-pellet cost of running 4 separate cooks.
A full rack of ribs serves 3–4 people. For 12 guests, you need 3 full racks plus sides. The standard Westwood fits 5 rib racks but not also vegetables and sides; the XL fits 7 racks plus full side dishes simultaneously.
Most KCBS and similar competitions require 4 separate proteins (chicken, ribs, pork, brisket). Running these on a 653 sq in surface requires multiple sequential cooks. The XL's 823 sq in fits all 4 simultaneously with proper indirect-heat zones.
28 chicken breasts on the XL = 4 weeks of meal-prep dinners for 2 people, or 2 weeks for a family of 4. The standard Westwood's 22 chicken breasts works but tighter — and gives less headroom for sides.
If your house is the de facto Memorial Day, July 4th, and Labor Day venue every year, the XL's headroom prevents the "are we going to have enough?" panic that happens 30 minutes before guests arrive. $100 to never-worry-about-grill-space-again is reasonable insurance.
Real Use Cases (Flip Side)
4–6 burgers, chicken thighs for 4, salmon fillets for 2, a tri-tip for date night. The standard Westwood's 653 sq in handles every weeknight cooking scenario for households of 1–6 people without crowding.
Smoking a single brisket or 2 racks of ribs for 6 guests doesn't need 823 sq in. The standard Westwood fits exactly this scenario with room for a vegetable tray.
The XL's larger footprint (~6 inches wider, ~4 inches deeper) matters when patio space is tight. The standard Westwood fits comfortably on 3' × 4' deck spaces; the XL needs 4' × 5' minimum.
If you've never owned a pellet grill, you don't yet know whether your cooking style will use 823 sq in regularly. Buy the standard, learn the platform, and upgrade in 3–5 years if you find yourself outgrowing it. Selling a used Westwood standard recovers ~$400–500; the depreciation cost is roughly the same as paying for the XL upfront.
If smoking is occasional rather than weekly, you'll never use the XL's headroom. Save the $100 for pellets, a wireless probe ($80), or a cast-iron sear grate accessory.
What the Spec Sheet Doesn't Show
The XL costs $100 more for cooking-area, but it costs other things too. First, assembly is harder. The XL ships in a heavier carton (~155 lbs vs ~130 lbs for the standard) and the larger barrel is awkward to position single-handedly. Plan 70–80 minutes for two-person assembly vs ~60 minutes on the standard.
Second, fuel efficiency is worse. The XL's larger cooking chamber means more interior volume to heat — that translates to roughly 15–20% more pellet consumption per cook at the same temperature. A bag of Traeger pellets that lasts 18 hours on the standard Westwood lasts ~15 hours on the XL.
Third, the pellet hopper is the same size on both. This is the underrated XL drawback. With an 18-lb hopper but higher pellet consumption, the XL needs hopper refills slightly more often — which is fine for shorter cooks but matters for 12+ hour brisket sessions where the standard might finish on a single hopper load and the XL might need a top-off.
Fourth, the footprint is meaningfully larger. The XL is wider, deeper, and heavier — harder to roll across patio steps, harder to fit through narrow gates, and harder to store in a covered area. Measure your space before assuming the XL fits where the standard would.
Reframe
The honest answer to "is the Westwood XL better than the standard Westwood?" is: they're the same grill. The XL has more cooking area; that's the entire feature delta. Asking "is XL better" is like asking "is a 36-inch TV better than a 32-inch TV?" — same TV, different screen size, your room dimensions decide which one is right.
The right question is: how often do I run out of cooking space, and how often do I host more than 6 people? If the answer to either is "frequently," the XL is the right buy. If the answer to both is "rarely," the standard is the right buy and you should put the $100 toward pellets, a wireless probe, or a Bear Mountain bulk-pellets order.
The trap is buying the XL because it's the "better" option and discovering 6 months in that you've never filled more than half the cooking surface. At that point you've paid $100 for headroom you don't use — and the XL's larger footprint, assembly burden, and pellet appetite are all costs you're paying for nothing.
FAQ
Pellet Grill Review
The full review of Traeger's $699 entry-level smart pellet grill — what it cuts vs the Woodridge and whether the closeout Pro 575 is the better deal.
Buying Guide
Full pellet-grill landscape: Traeger, Weber, Pit Boss, Recteq, and more across every price tier.
Grill Comparison
The other Westwood comparison — new $699 launch vs the discontinued $500–600 Pro 575 closeout. Pricing-tier decision math.
Grill Comparison
Is the $200 jump to the base Woodridge worth it? Honest answer — the base Woodridge does NOT have Super Smoke. What you actually get for the upgrade.
Accessories Hub
Cover, pellets, wireless probe, ModiFIRE Sear Grate, and P.A.L. attachments — 16 accessories ranked for every Westwood owner.